It came to my attention last night that there are a lot of girls just out here winging it when it comes to cooking steaks! NO BABY NO! You either take FOREVER, or you overcook the outside of it, or they are just plain and rough....and the men and children of the world are eating these from you keeping their mouths shut because they care! NO MORE! Here are my tips. Tips to excellent steaks that NEVER disappoint.
My Steak Tips (see the pun)
Plan ahead. Marinating steaks is the KEY to juicy, soft, tasty steaks. The night before you plan to cook them is the best time to thaw and marinate. Just put the frozen steaks in the fridge to thaw. When you wake up, they will be thawed or at least partially. ADD MARINADE. ANY KIND even if its just Worcestershire sauce. Let it sit in a bowl marinating until you are ready to make them! IF YOU DECIDE LAST MINUTE do not fear! Nesha is here! Simply defrost them 1/3 of the way, then pour marinade over frozen steaks and let it smother them while they continue to defrost in the microwave.
SEASON WHILE YOU MARINATE. This is so important. Dont put dry seasoning on dry steak, it might cook into the skin, but it is just a surface decoration. You want your flavor to be all the way to the deep middle of that steak. NO EXCUSES. So when you marinade the steaks, season them with a slight pinch of seasoning.
AVOID SALT WHILE COOKING STEAKS. Just don't do it. It has a tendency to dry out the meat if you're not careful, and I hate to say it, but some of you are just not ready to use salt. I eat your potlucks. And I am judging your salt use. If anyone eating your tender juicy steak needs salt, let them handle it. I have a record running of my steaks barely needing any SAUCE much less salt or pepper, and you can too!
DON'T BE AFRAID OF THE OVEN. To be fair, I think it is easier to cook them in the oven than it is on the stovetop or grill. TO COOK IT IN THE OVEN you simply put cuts of butter on the bottom of your glass baking pan, add your steaks, add some onions and peppers or some kind of sauce on top, and cover with aluminum foil. Bake at 375 until they are brown on the outside and check the middles to see what level they are cooked at. This makes the absolute JUICIEST steaks. You can also wrap up some corn on the cob (with a cube of butter) or potatoes in foil and bake them with it, They will be soft and juicy just like the steaks!!
LOW HEAT = GOOD EVEN COOKING and ELIMINATES overcooking, toughness, dryness, and 99% of your other problems. Girls are messing up steaks repeatedly because they think if the meat doesn't sizzle and smoke when you throw it down, you're not doing it right. WRONG. LOW HEAT is the key, NEVER cook a steak on ANYTHING over medium heat. EVER. Stay between low and medium. This does many things. It keeps your meat from overcooking on the OUTSIDE and not on the INSIDE. It keeps the juices from cooking out at high temps. This helps it stay juicy and also keeps it from being tough! It helps you keep a better handle on how done it is, so you can cook them perfectly to taste. It keeps the seasoning or rubs you may use from burning on the outside of the steak. It helps you have time to prepare your sides. EVEN ON THE GRILL low heat is the best way to cook the steak.....ask anyone Dad who has been the grill at the family bbqs for 30 years...he will tell you it takes years for people to figure that out...a lot of good steaks are eaten in their least amazing form.
IF COOKING MORE THAN ONE ON THE STOVE but doing it one at a time, take them off BEFORE they are done as they need to be. Place on a pan with a small piece of butter under it, COVER IT WITH FOIL and stick it in the oven on like 100 or 200 or something while you cook the rest. This will not only keep them warm, but they won't get all hard or lose their juices!
DO NOT be afraid to spice things up. Your best friend when it comes to steaks. What makes a plain steak a wonderful steak? Add ons. Gravy. Slices of peppers on top. Onions. Onions and peppers. Onions and gravy. WHATEVER!!! When the 2nd side of your steak is cooking it is ok to add peppers and things to the pan with a little oil (if needed). Either use the oil or the juices from your steak to brown and soften them, then throw them on the top of your steak.
COVER YOUR MEAT. When you marinade over night...cover it. When you are putting it in the oven...cover it. When it is cookin in a skillet...COVER IT! Why? JUICES. The absolute most important part of the steak. KEEP THEM IN YOUR STEAK.
Avoid over seasoning. This is something I can not stress enough. TASTE YOUR MARINADE. If you think it is bold tasting, DO NOT add seasoning. Make sure your SEASONING matches your MARINADE. You are about to follow Nesha's tips and make a juicy delicious steak. I know your mom says you need 5 handfuls of season all on steaks but I promise no one REALLY likes it. The less seasoning you use the better. The key is to make your steak taste good WITHOUT over seasoning. Seasoning barely makes it past the first layer of the steak, so STOP over doing it.
Be mindful. Cooking a steak is like meat chemistry. You have to add the perfect amount of flavor, with the perfect amount of heat, with the right amount of containment, with the right process with the right amount of time to reach a perfect finale. Do not take it lightly. Respect the steaks and they will respect you.
You can also use a crockpot if you don't have any picky eaters. If everyone will eat it medium well to well, throw some butter, your steaks, and all the leftover marinade juices (some onions and peppers if you want) in the crock and let it cook 3 - 4 hours or so on low. Check it, if needed turn up the heat.
I have a billion marinade recipes, so if you ever need one don't be afraid to ask! I will try to get a post up in the next few days listing a few of my favorites. They also have REALLY GOOD mixes at the grocery store. There are also crockpot seasoning kits that are absolutely GREAT with steaks as well! Find something that is a good flavor everyone will like, but that won't overpower your steaks! As for everything else, only you can improve this skill. If this post saves 1 family from eating dull, chewy, dry steaks....my mission is complete.